L'Oréal voluminous!! It is an all around great mascara. It gives me the thickness I am looking for and doesn't clump. That is very important!! Another very important feature for me, it doesn't tear my eyelashes out to take it off. It comes off pretty easy. I prefer the carbon black, non waterproof. I have never been a fan of waterproof though, it's too hard for me to get off!;) The color is rich and not grey. The original voluminous is pretty fantastic too.
Give it a try and let me know what you think.